Welcome: Non-Stanley Cup-winning goalie Marty Turco
I hate that every time someone wrote or said something about Antti Niemi, they had to put “Stanley Cup-winning” in front of his name. Even now after the the Blackhawks decided to walk away from Niemi and the one-year, $2.75 million extension decided by an arbiter, there it is: “Stanley Cup-winning.”
Now that the Blackhawks’ goalie story is complete and they have signed Marty Turco to a $1.3 million deal, “twice-as-expensive” Antti Niemi or “still relatively unknown” Antti Niemi would be a more significant way to describe him. Because even though $2.75 million is probably a fair price for Niemi, the Stanley Cup-winning goalie isn’t worth twice as much as the reliable Turco.
“Stanley Cup-winning” is accurate, of course, it’s just not the most important factor in deciding to keep Niemi or not. It would have been a mistake for the Hawks to re-sign Niemi just because he won the Cup with them last season. Compared to the ruthless, rational decisions the Hawks have been forced to make this offseason, this would have been the opposite. If the front office thought Niemi was twice good, even nearly twice as good, they would have pulled the trigger, moved another player or two and signed Niemi.
They didn’t think Niemi was any of those things.
The Hawks didn’t let a few good weeks in the playoffs overrule that Niemi has only played in 61 total games and that we still don’t know how consistently good he can be. Teams that make decisions based on the past, especially small sample sizes in the past, usually come to regret them.
“Generally, playoff runs are money in the bank for goaltenders,” writes The Score’s Jonathan Willis. Front office decision-makers in all sports tend to over-emphasize playoff runs, allowing good, recent playoff performances to overrule other factors (experience, the player’s age, health or how good they really think he is).
With Niemi, this didn’t happen with the Blackhawks. And I think they’re all the better for it.
For a brief roundup of scores and news from the non-Chicago teams that matter, continue reading.
Continue reading …